Thursday, 25 February 2016

Final Heroes


(Originally published Feb 25, 2016, at JRPGsaredead.fyi)

A thought I keep having lately:

What was the last Final Fantasy game with a male hero?

I don't mean a male protagonist (Tidus) or a male viewpoint character (Vaan). There's a difference, too, between being heroic and being a hero, and another between being a hero and being the hero. It's the last of these senses that I'm interested in here.

I take 'the hero' of a story to be the character who saves whatever it is the story centres on the saving of (or, more likely, the character who leads whatever effort it is ultimately achieves that saving). A possible alternative account would be that the hero is the character on whose virtues and vices turns the saving whatever is to be saved. These are necessarily imprecise and shouldn’t be taken as 'definitions', just flexible guides to what I have in mind.


So, which Final Fantasy[1] last had a male hero?

Whatever Snow might think, it's clearly not any of the FFXIII games. Taken as a trilogy, the hero is clearly Lightning. There are cases to be made that Fang and Vanille are the heroes of the first game, and Serah the hero of the second, though individuating the games like this risks losing nuances of the wider project.

I've dug into FFXII's Vaan before. Suffice it to say that, however important Vaan's presence is to FFXII as a complete work, there is no plausible reading according to which he, rather than Ashe, is the hero. Similarly, Basch is too much Ashe's follower, and Balthier altogether too superfluous, to displace her.

What about Tidus? FFX's protagonist is certainly more important to his game's events than Vaan or Snow to theirs. I think it's clear, though, that his metaphysical alienation from the modern Spira limits his ability to actually save anything. He supports Yuna's effort to save the world, definitely, and does so in ways that no other character does or could, but ultimately Yuna does the saving, and so is the hero.

I think it's fairly uncontroversial to say that both FFVII and FFVIII have male heroes. I don't really know FFIX well enough as yet to make a judgement – I'm eagerly awaiting the Steam release to rectify this oversight – but my impression is that things are more balanced between Zidane and Garnet than between, say, Squall and Rinoa. Even if hero duties ultimately fall squarely to Zidane, though, it's been fifteen-plus years since Square/Enix released a Final Fantasy whose hero was male.


I'm not saying this to attribute some great feminist virtue to Square's developers (in fact the opposite could be argued), nor as a simplistic defence of FFXV's all-male central cast, though I do think it establishes a context that makes the latter phenomenon more interesting. Instead I want to look at it as interrelated with (either caused by, a cause of, or some mix of the two) a general shift in how Final Fantasy has presented and engaged with the concept of heroism, and videogame heroism specifically.

There are multiple ways to state my underlying thesis, none of them perfect:

  • 'Heroism' is a male concept and in trying to create female heroes, Squenix designers had to develop a new concept of heroism.
  • In trying to develop new, more critical notions of 'heroism', Squenix designers found it necessary to dissociate heroism from male characters.
  • The way we relate to traditional notions of heroism is such that any female character placed in a heroic role will seem masculine.
  • The way we relate to traditional notions of heroism is such that any female character placed in a heroic role will seem implausible.

I could go on, but I've made enough of a mess already. Some of these claims require sociological or psychological evidence I'm not qualified or trained to obtain. Others would at least require some journalism I'm not willing or able to do. It is difficult to state a 'purely aesthetic' thesis as such, though, particularly since nothing can be 'purely aesthetic' in this sense; the use of socio-political signposts is inescapable.

Still, there are enough different approaches here that we can do some triangulating. Clearly, the nature of (video game) heroism is central to what I'm getting at. So is some idea of associations between aspects of that nature and gender. Both the perspectives on gender held by specific individuals – designers and writers employed at various times by Square/Enix – and those that exist as more general patterns in our society[2] are called into question.

Heroism

I've written before about the idea of 'hero privilege', a distinctive way in which characters framed as heroes in fantasy stories relate to the societies that they move through. It can be summed up this way: because a hero encodes a normative value (i.e. heroism requires or entails 'doing good'), if they come into conflict with society over a question of value, the hero defaults to being morally right. If society opposes the hero, society is in the wrong.

This means that things which we ordinarily value, like democracy, self-determination, free agency and human rights, if they belong to characters who are tokens of society in a heroic narrative, may be overridden. The people (or at least people-tokens) who make up a society can be comprehensively dehumanised purely because they stand between the hero and objectives the hero has deemed necessary.

This pattern is found across a wide range of media involving the heroic fantasy narrative (the most familiar example may be the police drama where the hero 'goes rogue' in order to stop a criminal who has evaded the legitimate methods of law enforcement), but it becomes particularly pernicious, I think, in video games. In some ways, JRPGs are most at risk of this problem, though the genre has also produced some of my favourite critical engagements with it.

Video games generally, or at least single-player-centric ones, naturally give a special place to one particular character or character-token – the one controlled by the player. Often games do their best to pretend otherwise, but characters in a game apart from those controlled by the player are not fully-rounded human beings with agency of their own.

What values a game ultimately expresses, then, will be shaped at least in significant part by the way the relationship between the player character and others is handled. If the player character is allowed to relate to the rest of their world's population as an abstraction only, a blob of simulated humanity to be saved or ignored, it suggests endorsement of the player character's 'specialness' – and possibly by extension treats the player themselves as special. Lana Polansky has written persuasively about how limiting this can be.

On the other hand, if other characters in the world are allowed to challenge the hero, if the hero's rightness isn't guaranteed, something much more nuanced can emerge. In 'real life', we have to deal with clashes of value and conflicting interests all the time. Our art should be able to engage with this, but it can't if one particular position or point of view within the work is given huge special treatment.

JRPGs tend to represent society in more abstract ways than most games[3]. Towns will be represented by a handful of NPCs, a couple of houses and a shop which sketches a hint of an economic situation. Social authority is often reserved solely for traditional authority figures – kings, parents, teachers – while other characters are little more than walking signposts.

This means that JRPGs are particularly susceptible to this problem. The player characters are often the only ones able to travel from town to town; they often become absurdly, economy-devastatingly rich; to add unimpeachable moral authority to that is to completely dismiss any humanity that 'ordinary' people in this fictional world might possess.

To their credit, narratively-focussed franchises like Tales and even Final Fantasy have done their best to engage with this. Still, the iconic Final Fantasy heroes, Cloud and Squall, certainly benefit from elements of this privilege. Cloud, particularly, exists in a world where the only major authority, the Shinra corporation, is clearly coded as evil. There is seldom any question over whether Cloud is right to challenge them, and, apart from other playable characters, he is seldom answerable to anyone else over whether or not he does.

Cloud and Squall are both presented as loners. The female heroes of the 21st-century Final Fantasy games, though, are more commonly seen in group contexts. Nowhere is this more apparent than with Yuna; Tidus, the player's viewpoint, spends the first third of the game watching Yuna interact with other people more than talking to her himself. On Besaid, Lulu and Wakka keep Tidus at arm's length while the locals crowd around to wish Yuna well. At Kilika, Yuna tends to the traumatised community in the wake of Sin's attack, more a priestess than a summoner.

It isn't really until the infamous laughing scene at Luca that Tidus gets to connect with Yuna directly. After that, episodes involving the Crusaders' Operation Mi'hen and Seymour's wedding continue to emphasise how much Yuna is a part of Spiran society, how many different factions have an interest in her and compete to determine her actions.

When Yuna and her guardians do finally turn against the expectations of society, it's a much less trivial thing than Cloud's opposition to Shinra. And the weight of their decision is reinforced by a sequel in which the transformation of the religious order, and resulting schism in society, dominate much of the plot.

For Ashe, as a princess trying to restore her kingdom, relationships to society are even more complex. Much of Ashe's journey is concerned with not just the fact but the legitimacy of her throne. Initially, she seeks proof of her lineage in order to appeal to such impartial authorities as Ivalice has, believing that if she can just establish herself as the legal ruler she will be able to at least negotiate with the occupying empire of Archadia.
When the Archadians reveal the extent to which they're willing to use force regardless of any legal or traditional authority, Ashe's quest switches to one for power. She seeks a weapon powerful enough to serve as a deterrent to further Imperial aggression. Much of what happens thereafter, though, from Vaan's presence to the devastated ruins of Nabradia, is structured to reveal the absurd moral compromise that weapons of mass destruction entail.

To whatever extent Ashe actually earns legitimacy as a ruler in the story, it comes from giving up such power; from not only throwing away her own opportunity to wield it, but from working to dismantle and stop the superweapons of others. The gods of Ivalice offer her the weapon she seeks, but only after she refuses them and those who seek to unseat them can she actually restore her kingdom.

With Lightning, things are twistier still. Lightning has no great heralded societal place; she's just a soldier. Being a soldier, and being the persona a woman – Claire Farron – has constructed in order to perform soldierhood, she is already divorced from the kind of social ties that Yuna and Ashe experience. By the start of FFXIII, Lightning has also cast off military authority and is acting on her own.

In fact, Lightning's determined preference for acting alone rings throughout the trilogy, right up until the final hours of Lightning Returns (about which I don't want to say too much because the Steam release is still fairly recent). But it does so because people keep placing demands on Lightning, not always without justification.

When Lightning frees Sazh in the middle of the Purge at the beginning of the game, she's obviously frustrated at his tagging along – but what else can he do? The game makes clear that his options are go with Lightning or fight and most likely die alone. Later, in the Vile Peaks, it's Hope who becomes the burden, this time grounded in a vague idea of connection between Lightning and Snow (of whom more later).

Lightning's old military organisation tries to lay claim to her in its power struggle with other factions in Cocoon's government. And there's the overarching question of which fal'cie power has claimed the party and in doing so forced them together – Lightning spends a long time trying to ignore her brand in favour of saving Serah.

So while Lightning definitely aspires to the solitary freedom of the hero, Final Fantasy XIII keeps finding ways to deny it to her. In the second game, Lightning gets her solitude, at the expense of being totally narratively inert – literally trapped outside of time – and having the focus shift onto her sister.

Serah, by the way, is consistently shown as deeply engaged with communities and social ties. She's a teacher, she lives with a group of close friends, her objectives in the game are always established according to the needs of local communities, and her only 'heroic' motivation is the restoration of her family, through getting Snow and Lightning back. The extent to which she's defined by this signifiers of archetypal femininity is heavy-handed, even clumsy at times.

Lightning Returns crams Lightning into a cramped, closed-circle world stuffed full of individual NPCs with distinct needs and objectives. Since the player can only raise Lightning's stats by completing their sidequests, Lightning is forced to draw power from specific social connections. Her only escape is to her base on the Ark, another place outside of time and space where Lightning can be a demigod, but only ineffectually.

LR also runs on a fixed internal clock – as long as Lightning is outside the Ark, time flows and cannot be clawed back. Sidequest-givers are only available at particular times, and once missed may be missed for good. The need to be in specific places at specific times to gain the power needed to complete the game is another way of limiting Lightning through social connections, of making concrete the demands society places on her.

Ultimately, the structure of the trilogy undercuts Claire Farron's attempt to perform the 'Lightning' persona. Given that FFXIII director Motomu Toriyama specifically asked Tetsuya Nomura to design Lightning as "a female version of Cloud from FFVII", the effect is a reflection on that earlier construction of the hero, and it shows just how far Final Fantasy's heroes have come.

I don't want to sound like I'm dunking on Cloud – his story is interesting. It's just the parts of it in which he is a hero, and the subsequent cultural understanding which remembers him purely as a brooding loner who fights Sephiroth, are among the least interesting. The story of Lightning, who wants to be the brooding loner fighting evil but is unable to deny the nuance demanded by her social and societal connections, addresses exactly this blind spot.

Gender

It's possible to see this shift in Final Fantasy's heroes as a product of their various writers' needs to break new storytelling ground – since at least Final Fantasy VII, Square Enix's devs have been under intense pressure to take the lead in this area. The traditional construction of heroism is familiar, sometimes to the point of tedium, and attempts to move beyond it will almost inevitably require critical engagement with it. The switch to female heroes could be a coincidence.

But we should be careful not to understate what it means to be a coincidence. We needn't prove that a decision to change to female heroes caused the shift in narrative types or vice versa in order to show that the two changes were connected. The link I want to argue for may be much subtler than direct one-way causation, but still much more substantial than coincidence.

Refining from my starting points, my claim is this: hero privilege and the more general male privilege are similar enough that we – and particularly the writers and narrative designers employed by mass-media companies like Square Enix – struggle to conceive of a character having one without the other. This is not to say that it's impossible, just that it's easy to not do. Standard ideas of innovation aren't enough.

Try to imagine a male hero coerced into a political marriage, as Yuna is. Male heroic characters can have political and tactical marriages – FFXII's Prince Rasler, for example – but because society still treats the 'husband' role as the authoritative one, these cannot pose a threat to their agency in the way that marriage to Seymour might subordinate Yuna's. To a male hero, a political marriage can be a tiresome but necessary symbol; to a female hero, it is by default an obstacle to be overcome, every bit as much as any boss fight.

Or consider the sequence in FFXII when Archadian officials steal the Dusk Shard from Ashe. Judge Ghis tells her, "We hold the proof of your royal lineage. A maid of passing resemblance will serve our purposes now." Ashe's body and person are dismissed outright. It is only Ashe-as-symbol that the antagonists are interested in, because no other part of Ashe presents a threat to them. It's a very clear statement against heroic actions that it's hard to imagine any but the youngest male heroes encountering. A male hero would normally never be reduced to his 'passing resemblance'.

There's another shift at work in the 21st-century Final Fantasies, too. Each game invokes male heroism in characters who ultimately prove ineffectual, or at least markedly less significant than their heroines.

Tidus is an endearing goof, sometimes important for his outsider's ability to think the unthinkable and sometimes important for the party's morale, but Yuna would have succeeded at being some kind of hero without him. Her place at the intersection of Yevon and Al Bhed cultures contributes as much to that as anything Tidus does.

Balthier is a more pitiful spectacle; a pampered rich kid playing at defiance and criminality as a flight from his troubled family situation. His repeated wisecracks about being 'the leading man', in context of the wider story, are a sad joke. Basch is a deeper character, but his narrative role is as little more than a vector for exposition and context.

With Snow in FFXIII, the franchise turned outright scornful. Snow is a childish fool whose playing at heroism, the game makes abundantly clear, gets people killed. That his gang's epithet is NORA – 'No Obligations, Rules or Authority' – makes him the most pointed comment yet on the dangerous irresponsibility of hero-privilege narratives.

Again, it's hard to imagine characters this ridiculous being female. A woman in the place of Snow or Balthier wouldn't be tolerated by those around her, or if she was would be regarded much more clearly as repugnant by the majority of the games' audiences. In mass media, men – or at least men who centrally benefit from male privilege, which is the group of men we see most of - get away with behaviour which from anyone else would be unacceptable.

Critiquing heroism goes hand-in-hand with critiquing masculinity, but that doesn't mean that there can't be better representations of either. Both Sazh (despite the harmful way his race is presented) and Hope in the FFXIII trilogy are given more nuanced treatment, a broad range of emotional expression and strong non-sexual social ties. Both are placed firmly in their social context and are answerable to other human beings.

Which leads naturally to the question of where Final Fantasy is headed next – Final Fantasy XV, a game with an apparently all-male playable cast, with director Hajime Tabata talking about a 'boys will be boys' story, that lifts the curtain on 'what boys do when girls aren't around'. Tabata's remarks are at best an awkward misstep, and definitely troubling, but, well...

What if the game actually does offer an alternative? What if it gives us men who, at least in character if not in identity, aren't like those we're used to seeing? Some of the signifiers of hero privilege are present, like the characters having the freedom to travel into the unknown, but the journey, framed as a roadtrip, seems more aimless than many. So far it's unclear what threatens the world, or how the characters' journey is supposed to help.

Taken on its own, another game with an all-male cast is a tedious prospect. As inheritor of the modern Final Fantasy tradition (and, indeed, Tabata's record for games that present healthier masculinities, like Crisis Core: Final Fantasy VII), though, there is at least the possibility of something more.




[1] I want to limit this to the 'major releases', but this is increasingly difficult to define. 'Home console releases' is more precise and I think captures what people mean when they muse about the trends, destiny and/or fate of the franchise. Let's assume for now that the MMOs, FFXI and FFXIV, can be safely overlooked, as well as handheld and mobile spinoffs. The Fabula Nova Crystallis (FFXIII) sequence is so coherent as a trilogy that I feel justified including all three games, though Type-0, as a handheld spinoff that was later ported to home consoles, is a tricky one, and entirely available as a gotcha against my pitch.

[2] It's vital to recognise that in certain crucial respects, Squenix's staff have never been members of our society. This limits what I can say because, again, I am not sociologist (or anthropologist) enough to have significant insight into the construction of gender in Japanese culture. I can talk from my own experience of our 'Western' (better: Anglo-American) culture, and I can speculate to an extent on how Final Fantasy games have increasingly been developed for an international market and audience, but these don't entitle me to leap the cultural gap.

[3] And to do so more as a matter of conscious choice than as a response to technological limitation, though certainly the traditional abstractions of the JRPG started as a response to technological constraints. To whatever extent 'the JRPG' is a coherent concept, it has always valued 'realism' (or 'literalism', or even just 'the concrete') less than western RPGs and other genres.

Monday, 4 January 2016

Final Fantasy XII and the Paradox of Final Fantasy

This is a transcript of my mini-episode for the Dead Genre Chronicles podcast (by the way, I'm on a podcast, check it out).




------

There is a paradox at the heart of what 'Final Fantasy' means in gaming. A Final Fantasy game must suffer two irreconcilable comparisons to the series' landmark seventh instalment; first, to the narrative and interface conventions it defined, and second to its astonishing transpacific impact. No game, or indeed any other work of art, could meet both, since landmark status can seldom if ever be achieved by preserving and perpetuating conventions.

Final Fantasy IX and X were commercially and critically successful, and still hold up today as excellent developments of the form and style laid down by Final Fantasy VII. They are outstanding games, deeply worthy of their heritage, but neither even approaches global landmark status.

Final Fantasy XII wasn't Square Enix's first attempt to break from the FFvii formula; even discounting handheld spin-offs, that honour goes to the misunderstood and underrated Finall Fantasy X-2. But where X-2 is an optimistic tale about the construction of new traditions, it is Final Fantasy XII that best expresses the frustration of the Final Fantasy paradox.


At a personal level, FFXII is the story of Ashelia B'nargin, princess of the recently-conquered kingdom of Dalmasca. Her adventure comprises a series of desperate attempts to restore her sovereignty and build a resistance to the grand empires that want to use her country as a battlefield.

But Ashe's actions are largely irrelevant to the history of Ivalice. At a political level, what really turns the world of FFXII are the tides of power and honour that bind the empires of Archadia and Rozarria to their cold war.

At every turn, Ashe and her party are thwarted by Archadia's effortless military and technological supremacy; more than once, hours of in-game travel will end in a cutscene where Archadian airships fly overhead, overtaking you and destroying whatever faint hope you journeyed in search of.

The true magnitude of the plot's commitment to futility can only be conveyed through spoilers, so if you want to avoid them skip ahead now.

####

We are used to Final Fantasy games where, in the end, the player's party challenge the power of Gods who wish to control the destiny of mankind. In Final Fantasy XII, though, it is the villains who chant about placing, as they put it, 'the reins of history back in the hands of man'. There are gods, the Occuria, who manipulate human affairs, by granting the powers of magical superweapons to some monarchs and not others; but it is Vayne and Cid who seek to break their monopoly.

Ashe – herself chosen by the Occuria to wield a new nethicite superweapon – defeats Vayne, having finally decided not to use the power of nethicite herself. In doing so, she allows the Occuria to remain in their position of absolute power and forswears the only thing that could make her political and military position secure. Though she ends the story with Dalmasca's sovereignty restored, the nation's army remains weak and the power of her neighbours stands almost unchecked.

It should be noted here that there's a distinctly Japanese relationship to the politics of nuclear weaponry at work in FFXII's plot, but it's a topic for another time, and for a critic who isn't tied by national and personal history to the development of nuclear power for military use.

### (end spoiler) ###

Very little is changed about the world of Final Fantasy XII by the actions of any character. Against the tides of history, individual agency is largely irrelevant. This is reinforced by the sheer scale of the slice of Ivalice you're permitted to explore. FFXII's playable areas are vast, but they also have open horizons that reveal just how much of the world is beyond reach.

It's a long game, and you travel what feels like an extraordinarily broad stretch of the world. But for all your wandering, you explore less than half of Archadia and never trouble the shores of Rozarria at all. This is the great advantage of unifying the game around a single scale rather than having the world-map/field-map dichotomy of older games (which is not to say that world-map-games are necessarily bad, just that FFXII gets excellent mileage out of the alternative).

I'd argue, though this is more subjective, that there is also an insignificance to the combat. There are no dramatic transitions between exploration and battle, few opportunities for a triumphant pose or the game's subdued version of the iconic victory theme. And the gambit system, which allows you to programme your own limited friendly A.I. rather than individually input commands, diminishes your moment-to-moment role in the fighting.


To truly address the motif of insignificance that runs through Final Fantasy XII, though, we have to talk about Vaan. Because while Ashe is clearly the protagonist and lead character of the game, it is Vaan who serves as our viewpoint on events, a less-intelligent Watson to Ashe's less-insufferable Holmes.

The story of FFXII's development is far from transparent, but something that's become widely-believed over the last ten years is that Vaan was a late addition to the cast, only added after Yasumi Matsuno's departure from the development team. Matsuno's departure is a complex issue in its own right – the official line is that he left due to illness, but rumours remain that he clashed with other key Squenix figures, or that creative differences drove him out.

The popular myth holds that after Matsuno's departure, his original protagonist was deemed too old to appeal to the core Final Fantasy fanbase, so Vaan was introduced as replacement. Opinion varies as to whether the original protagonist became Basch or Balthier, or whether the character disappeared entirely.

I haven't been able to find an unambiguous source for any of this. Certainly, elements of the game's story changed after Matsuno's departure, but this is to be expected on any large video game. The ambiguity leaves a cloud hanging over Vaan, particularly as the idea that fans of JRPGs couldn't handle a 'mature' character feeds into a trite, overplayed narrative about the kind of people who like Japanese games.

Still, I feel Vaan is absolutely essential to the thematic project of Final Fantasy XII. He is the ultimate in insignificance; orphaned and stripped of his family by the war, he lives by street crime and odd jobs in the capital of Ashe's kingdom. Though he is close enough to the familiar hero-of-humble-stock to pass for it on first inspection, Vaan is not really any kind of hero at all.

Vaan is an NPC given life. In any other JRPG, he'd be the street-savvy kid hanging around near the airship dock with big dreams and little concept of the outside world. He'd have three different dialogue boxes, one in each act, indicating a steadily-growing awareness of the stakes at work in your quest.

So why cart such an inconsequential character around with the heroic Princess for seventy-plus hours? Why force him between the player and the game? When he displays any character at all, he's unquestionably annoying.

Yes, thank you, child.
The relationship between Vaan and Ashe brings out the absurdity of the relationship between Final Fantasy's magical heroes and the undifferentiated mass of virtual bodies they claim intent to save. Vayne's quarrel with the Occuria is irrelevant to the citizens and subjects of Archadia. Only the most powerful men in Ivalice are more oppressed by the Gods than by human rulers.

For Vaan, no theological quibble can be worth the threat that the Occuria's nethicite poses to his friends in Rabanastre. Ashe contemplates the use of nethicite as a weapon of war; Vaan's mere presence represents those who would be destroyed. He highlights the distance between Ashe's idea of her subjects' needs and the actual experiences of her people.

Ashe stands between Vayne's might and Vaan's insignificance. Technically a divinely-entitled monarch, she should be free to challenge the gods, but her claim to heroism rests in principles that demand she not use the tools presented. Vaan represents the second horn of this dilemma. It would be trite and inaccurate to call him the voice of Ashe's conscience; instead, he is a prompt to the player's awareness.

Were Ashe to be the viewpoint character, the conventions of the Final Fantasy series would preclude any possibility of considering this tension. We might see the precarity of Rabanastre's citizens in occasional NPC dialogue, but we have been trained out of identifying with these digital sheep. We trust that the game will enable us to save them, except for those that will be sacrificed in some spectacular cutscene to symbolise the stakes.

Vaan forces us into their perspective, makes us understand why it is that the means of heroes must be limited, cautious, and surgical. If this limits their ability to transform the world, perhaps we should reevaluate the idea that the world is in need of transformation.

It's no coincidence that this question appeared in FFX-2, and went on to reappear in the sequels to Final Fantasy XIII (itself a game about the inevitability of dire fates). But Final Fantasy XII states the question most clearly: for whom do we transform the world, and at what cost?


FFXII gives a hopeful answer. When Ashe and Vaan finally get their moment at the fulcrum of history, they choose to give up the possibility of nethicite power, to place it beyond reach of another human epoch. This is the answer that places the principles that underlie heroism ahead of the empty egoism that so often goes in their place. It's Bruce Wayne choosing to fund public infrastructure and advocating progressive taxation instead of dressing up as a bat and growling at people.

And Final Fantasy XII is defiantly hopeful about Final Fantasy as a project. It treats the Final Fantasy rulebook with the same forward-looking disregard that Final Fantasy VII once did. It rejects, or gives up on, the attempt to equal FFVII by imitating it. It recognises the impossibility of pleasing everyone who will try to claim some ownership of the Final Fantasy brand or identity.

So it's sad to see, half a decade later, the grim fatalism of FFXIII. It's hard to read that as anything other than a response to the hostile reception of FFXII. The recent furore over the Final Fantasy VII remake trailers has only emphasised this sense of futility; every feature of the original game has become a battleground between those who consider it essential and those who hold it to be anachronistic. By the time the remake emerges, the game's fan base may have entirely self-cannibalised. 

But on the other hand, there's Final Fantasy XV, a game of massive areas with open, stunning horizons. A game that enshrines a journey, and where, at least in the demo, the armies of a powerful empire occasionally swoop effortlessly overhead to attack you. A game that locks you to a single, small scale in a vast world. Possibly a game that, in completing the Fabula Nova Crystallis sequence, will finally break its fascination with the inevitable. The paradox of Final Fantasy may yet see resolution.

-----